Welcome back for part two! If you haven’t checked out the first half of this list, I strongly encourage you to do so—there are some gems you don't want to miss. Here are my top five Halloween movies.
5. Late night with the devil (2023)
Why it’s on my list:
It’s possible I’m biased by how recent this film is, but there’s no denying its impact. The movie offers a bit of everything: psychic mediums, demonic possession, worm phobia, and even a live stage band. The 1970s vibe comes through perfectly, making it feel like a true late-night Halloween special that redefines "must-see TV."
Why you should watch it:
Ever thought about selling your soul to excel at something you're passionate about? Prefer staying in and watching late-night TV on Halloween? Fascinated by live TV gone terribly wrong? Late Night with the Devil delivers the goods if you answered yes to any of these questions. It’s a fun, original twist on some of our favorite horror tropes
4. Terrifier 2 (2022)
Why it’s on my list:
I must admit, this was my first exposure to the franchise, having missed the 2016 original. Terrifier introduces a fresh slasher character who feels original rather than a rehash of old favorites. It’s packed with gore and impressive kills, and Damien Leone pulls off a 2:18 runtime that surprisingly doesn’t feel too long.
Why you should watch it:
Are you a horror fan constantly searching for more killer clown content? Do you like the idea of becoming an "art house" aficionado, crafting your own Halloween costumes? Leone raised funds for this film without the backing of major studios, proving that a determined artist can beat the odds. Originally slated for just a one-week release, it became a box office hit—a true testament to independent filmmaking.
3. Donnie Darko (2001)
Why it’s on my list:
First before you scream and smash your Halloween 3 VHS over your head, I know some of you might argue this is more science fiction than horror, but it’s perfect for a Halloween night watch. If adults still insist Hocus Pocus is a horror movie, Donnie Darko surely qualifies. The cast is phenomenal, a virtual “who’s who” of powerhouse actors. I’d love to explain the plot, but every time I rewatch it, I seem to understand less than before.
Why you should watch it:
Do you like to think of yourself as an amateur philosopher or deep thinker? Ever feared dying from falling airplane debris? While this movie demands a bit more brainpower than your average Halloween film, it's worth it. With time-traveling rabbits, Patrick Swayze as a self-help guru, and the unforgettable choreography of Sparkle Motion, it’s a must-see.
2. The Witch (2015)
Why it’s on my list:
Pilgrims battling witchcraft in the woods is an ideal premise for Halloween night. This film nails historical authenticity, and the acting—especially from a young Anya Taylor-Joy—is outstanding. The dark cinematography and ominous atmosphere keep you guessing: Is it demonic forces at play, or are the children just messing with everyone?
Why you should watch it:
Looking for a historically accurate period piece featuring a talking animal? Ever wondered what it would be like to survive off the land while battling Satan? The Witch will keep you on the edge of your seat, with an overwhelming sense of dread from start to finish. And let’s not forget the standout performance from Black Phillip!
1. Halloween (1978)
Why it’s on my list:
Was there ever any doubt that the grandfather of all slashers would top this list? While there’s debate over whether it was the first slasher, its lasting impact on the genre is undeniable. With the embodiment of evil, an iconic score, and Jamie Lee Curtis delivering one of the best "final girl" performances in history, it’s the perfect way to spend Halloween night.
Why you should watch it:
Are you a fan of mental health professionals who go above and beyond for their patients? Ever held a grudge a little longer than you should have? If you haven’t seen Halloween and consider yourself a horror fan, stop what you’re doing and watch it immediately. For me, it’s a proud Halloween tradition and an essential October viewing.